The invasive alien tree Golden wattle (Acacia pycnantha) (Photo credit: Jaco Le Roux)
Making decisions about the clearing of invasive alien plants is not an easy process. Despite a plethora of academic
literature and practical examples, managers continue to rely on experience and anecdotes instead of using scientific findings. This
so-called “science-practice gap” receives a lot of attention in the scientific literature, with natural resource managers
often being criticized for not using scientific evidence when making decisions in their day-to-day operations. However, little regard
is given to the practical constraints that managers experience in their work environments.
A study led by former doctoral student Dr Phumza Ntshotsho, involving C·I·B staff and collaborators at
the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), assessed the use of scientific evidence in the management of invasive alien
plants in South Africa.
Using the national Department of Environmental Affairs’ Working for Water (WfW) program as a case study, the researchers
showed that there are several factors that determine the extent to which science is used in decision-making. For example, the
institutional context within which decision makers operate plays an important role. Organizational structure, policies, priorities and
capacity influence, and may even limit, the use of scientific evidence when making decisions.
“Our findings highlight the importance of conducting research with the end user in mind. Being cognisant of
other factors that may affect the practical utility of our science may encourage closer collaboration with decision makers”
says Phumza. “Co-producing knowledge with end users would increase the potential for its application, which would ultimately
mean we are doing impactful science”, she concludes.
Read the paper:
Ntshotsho, P., Prozesky, H.E.,
Esler, K.J. & Reyers, B. 2015. What drives the use of scientific evidence in decision making? The case of the South African Working
for Water program. Biological Conservation 184: 136-144.
For more information, contact Phumza Ntshotsho at firstname.lastname@example.org