Large-scale fire experiment in Kruger National Park, South Africa, used to test the effectiveness of high
intensity fires for reducing the cover of woody shrubs
(Photo credit: Izak Smit)
Repeated high-intensity fires can reduce bush encroachment, but they also speed up the loss of tall trees. These findings came
from a recent study by a team of researchers including C·I·B Core Team Member, Brian van Wilgen, and were published in the
Journal of Applied Ecology.
Grasslands and open savannas are continuously being invaded by woody plants (a phenomenon commonly called bush encroachment)
and scientists predict that the extent of this phenomenon will grow as the levels of CO2 in the atmosphere increase. Herbicides or
mechanical clearing can be used to reverse bush encroachment, but are expensive and impractical over large areas. One suggested method to
reverse bush encroachment is the use of high intensity fires that would reduce woody shrub cover, while leaving tall trees unaffected.
To test this idea, South African National Parks, with logistical support from Working on Fire conducted a fire experiment to
see whether high intensity fires could be used to reverse bush encroachment in the Kruger National Park. Using LiDAR remote sensing technology,
the team of authors from South African National Parks, Carnegie Institution of Science and C·I·B compared the vegetation cover
and height in areas exposed to repeated high intensity and low intensity fires, as well as areas protected from fire, before and after the
different fire treatments.
Findings following the fire treatments
The research team found that two successive high intensity fires reduced bush cover. In comparison, the areas burnt by two
successive low intensity fires became even denser over the 4 year study period.
“The high intensity fire was successful, at least in the short term, in reducing bush cover, but we were surprised
at the number of tall trees, exceeding 10 meters, that collapsed following high intensity fires” says van Wilgen.
Tall trees are normally considered to be unaffected by fires because their canopies are above the “flame-zone”,
but in this experiment, more than a third of tall trees collapsed after two successive high intensity fires. Trees were apparently vulnerable
to high intensity fires because elephants remove bark within the “flame-zone” height which causes the wood to dry and become
vulnerable to wood borer infestations. These “weak” points enable high intensity fires to set the stem alight and lead to toppling
of the tree.
“We were hoping our results would show that high intensity fires could be used to reduce cover of encroaching shrubs.
Although we confirmed this, at least in the short term, the accompanying damage to tall trees creates a management conundrum”
explains van Wilgen.
Van Wilgen and co-authors suggest “that one solution may be to repeatedly apply high-intensity treatments to some
areas, and not to others, to generate a heterogeneous landscape where grasses become dominant and tall trees scarce in some places, but in
others tall trees remain and shorter woody shrubs increase. We predict that in areas without elephants or with lower elephant densities, high
intensity fires may have less of an impact on tall trees”.
Pre- and post-fire information of the same area, showing how 3D vegetation structure was affected by high intensity
fire (black shows ground cover, and grey-to-white shows the increasing height of woody vegetation; blue lines show examples of large-canopied
trees observable both before and after fire treatments, whereas the red circle highlight an area where fire reduced cover of small shrubs)
(Image credit: Izak Smit)
Read the full paper by Smit et al.
Smit, I.P.J., Asner, G.P.,
Govender, N., Vaughn, N. and van Wilgen, B.W. 2016. An examination of the potential efficacy of high intensity fires for reversing woody
encroachment in savannas. Journal of Applied Ecology
For more information, contact Brian van Wilgen at firstname.lastname@example.org